There's only one part of what I said that's arguably unreasoning, and that's the relative weight of their talents. And I still believe, based on decades of listening to both, that Sandy Denny was far more talented than Grace Slick. That's not to say Grace Slick was untalented, but, um, Starship? She did an awful lot of dreck.
But my main point is that the poll results reflect name recognition, not talent. Sandy Denny, for all her importance and talent, is little known in the US. The one recording most American music fans have heard, they don't know is her (cf Led Zeppelin's "Battle of Evermore"). But everyone here has heard of Grace Slick.
No, pretty much the entire thing is unreasoning, except for the words "I suspect this".
You start with These results are Just. Plain. Wrong., and your only argument is to try to invalidate the poll. First saying that I suspect this poll reflects name recognition, not talent. ... which also implies that the folks who voted cannot possibly be well informed, since they disagreed with you. And then Sandy Denny had more talent in her pinkie than Grace Slick has ever shown, which is just plain silly. Grace was one of the most important and formidable voices of her generation.
And then in your reply, once again your only way of defending Sandy is to put down Grace That's not to say Grace Slick was untalented, but, um, Starship? She did an awful lot of dreck.
Grace did one of the worst things that an icon can do, she survived and went on to her dreck years. Sandy died in the beginning stages of hers.
You've said very little positive about the singer that you claim to love, and a lot to put down the person who won this poll ... which is what makes this raving fanboy silliness.
Defending someone by putting someone else down is a pretty lazy way to form an argument.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2009-04-25 05:19 pm (UTC)But my main point is that the poll results reflect name recognition, not talent. Sandy Denny, for all her importance and talent, is little known in the US. The one recording most American music fans have heard, they don't know is her (cf Led Zeppelin's "Battle of Evermore"). But everyone here has heard of Grace Slick.
no subject
Date: 2009-04-26 12:08 am (UTC)You start with , and your only argument is to try to invalidate the poll. First saying that ... which also implies that the folks who voted cannot possibly be well informed, since they disagreed with you. And then , which is just plain silly. Grace was one of the most important and formidable voices of her generation.
And then in your reply, once again your only way of defending Sandy is to put down Grace
Grace did one of the worst things that an icon can do, she survived and went on to her dreck years. Sandy died in the beginning stages of hers.
You've said very little positive about the singer that you claim to love, and a lot to put down the person who won this poll ... which is what makes this raving fanboy silliness.
Defending someone by putting someone else down is a pretty lazy way to form an argument.